Rustic with Love

425 Center Street • Lewiston, NY 14092  •  (716) 754-2311
Tues | Wed | Thur (5-9)    Fri | Sat (5-9:30)

OpenTable Reservations

Chef Carmelo Raimondi

“FOOD is like LIFE…
The less you complicate it, the better it tastes.”

~ Chef Carmelo Raimondi


Dining at Carmelo’s is an adventure.
Enjoy the taste sensations of this season, while looking forward to the next.

Because we maintain only fresh ingredients and create fresh presentations
our menu varies from day to day.

Here’s a taste  – sample menu items from FEBRUARY 23, 2016


citrus marinated olives: 6
pei mussels: jalapeno pesto, fries, parsley 12
pork & veal meatballs: san marzano tomato sauce, smoked mozzerella 12
deviled eggs: house smoked arctic char, crispy focaccia crumbs 10
polenta: baked egg, rosemary, extra virgin olive oil 10
capocolo, usa: pickled vegetables, cheese, olives 12
 chicken liver mousse: fig mostarda, pickled endive, dicamillo toast 9


red beet & fennel: almond, feta cheese, olive & orange vinaigrette 10
lobster: butter poached, caesar vinaigrette, garlic breadcrumbs 16
crispy rhode island calamari: chili-lime vinaigrette, smoked peanuts 13
house: mixed greens, gorgonzola, parsnip sticks, balsamic-rosemary vinaigrette 9

PASTA (house made) & POLENTA

spaghetti: broccoli rabe, chili flakes, anchovy 15
linguine: pei mussels, garlic, extra virgin olive oil 18
orecchiette: wild florida gulf shrimp, vodka-tomato sauce 22
lumache: pork & beef bolognese, crispy pancetta 23
polenta: stillwater farm lamb ragu, mint gremolata 24


atlantic cod: stewed cannellini beans and greens, spicy breadcrumbs 17
filet of beef: lemon risotto, blueberry-balsamic sauce 38
all natural chicken: salsa verde, crisp lettuces, roasted chicken jus 16
scottish salmon: lump crab, lentils, potato, saffron tomato fumet 25
new york strip: poached egg, mushroom-potato hash, red wine sauce 35
pork chop: cipollini, braised cabbage, radish, grain mustard agliata 24
veal chop porterhouse: potato puree, broccoli rabe, mushroom-marsala sauce 35


 crispy potatoes: herbs & parmigiano 7
pan roasted cauliflower: lemon, thyme & pecorino 8
crispy brussels sprouts: honey-mustard vinaigrette 8

Fine Wine

Fine Wine

Summer Kiss Cocktail


3 Beer Taps

Craft Beer

425 Center Street • Lewiston, NY 14092
(716) 754-2311

Tues | Wed | Thur 5-9
Fri | Sat 5-9:30

Powered By: